Buying out your spouse vs selling the business in a divorce usually comes down to one question: can the spouse who stays pay a fair price without starving the company? In Texas, a buyout generally fits when one spouse runs a healthy business and can fund the payment. Selling fits when neither spouse wants the company, financing fails, or only a real buyer can settle the price.
The short verdict
For an operating company that one spouse runs, we would test the buyout first. It keeps the business intact, it generally avoids a taxable event at the time of the transfer, and it can be finished inside the divorce. Move to a sale when the buyout only works on paper, meaning the payments depend entirely on the company’s future performance and the departing spouse has little real security.
Texas law does not choose for you. Texas Family Code § 7.001 tells the court to divide the estate in a manner it deems just and right, and § 7.006 lets spouses write their own division, with terms that bind the court if it finds them just and right. That means the two of you can build a structure a judge might never design at trial, which is a strong reason to run the numbers on both options before mediation.
Buyout vs sale at a glance
| Factor | Buying out your spouse | Selling the business |
|---|---|---|
| Who ends up with the company | The spouse who keeps it, usually the operator | A third-party buyer |
| How the price is set | An agreed number or a valuator’s opinion, tested in mediation or at trial | What a real buyer pays after due diligence |
| Federal tax at closing | Generally no gain or loss on a transfer incident to divorce, but the existing basis carries over (26 U.S.C. § 1041) | Gain is generally recognized, at rates up to 20% for most long-term gain (IRS Topic 409) |
| Transaction costs | Valuator, lawyers, any loan fees | Broker commission from 5% to 12% or more, commonly around 10% (Robbinex), plus lawyers and accountants |
| Cash to the departing spouse | At once if funded by other assets or a loan; over time if funded by a note | At closing, less any holdback or earnout |
| Timing | Can be completed in the decree, which generally cannot be granted before the 60th day after filing (Tex. Fam. Code § 6.702) | Depends on finding a buyer, so it can delay the decree or run past it |
| Main risk | The owner overpays, or the note goes unpaid | The deal fails, the price disappoints, or key staff leave during the process |
| Ties after the divorce | None once paid; a note keeps the former spouses connected until then | Few, apart from any holdback, earnout or indemnity claims |
Texas rules that shape the choice
Start with character. Property either spouse holds during or at the end of the marriage is presumed community, and overcoming that takes clear and convincing evidence under § 3.003. If the company is truly separate property, there may be nothing to buy out, though a reimbursement claim can still be in play. We cover that sorting in Divorcing with a Business in Texas.
Know what is divisible. In Nail v. Nail, 486 S.W.2d 761 (Tex. 1972), the Texas Supreme Court held that goodwill resting on a physician’s personal skill, experience and reputation was not divisible property. So a buyout valuation may carve out personal goodwill while counting goodwill that belongs to the enterprise. A sale price does not sort itself that way. Part of what a buyer pays may depend on the owner’s reputation, a transition period or a noncompete, and how to treat that part becomes a negotiating point between the spouses.
Read the company documents. Under Tex. Bus. Orgs. Code § 101.1115, a spouse who ends up with an LLC interest on divorce is an assignee of that interest, and the chapter does not impair an agreement to buy or sell an interest on divorce. So splitting the units in half often gives the non-owner spouse an economic stake without a member’s role, which is one reason continued co-ownership tends to appeal to few couples. An existing buy-sell agreement may also set a price or a process, and loan documents may restrict a transfer. Check all of them before you talk numbers.
Do not sell or borrow on your own. A temporary restraining order under § 6.501 can bar selling or encumbering property and destroying financial records. Temporary orders under § 6.502 can give one spouse exclusive control of a party’s usual business or appoint a receiver to preserve property. Collin County’s district courts, located at 2100 Bloomdale Rd. in McKinney, also post a Standing Order on Children, Property, & Conduct of Parties. Read the order that applies in your county before you sign a letter of intent or pledge the company for a loan. Moving value out of the community can also lead to a fraud claim and a reconstituted estate under § 7.009.
Assume you get one shot at the terms. After the decree, § 9.006 lets the court enforce and clarify the division, but only if the substantive division is not altered. A vague buyout clause is hard to repair later.
The tax difference is often the deciding number
A direct transfer between spouses incident to divorce generally produces no gain or loss, and the receiving spouse takes the transferor’s basis, under 26 U.S.C. § 1041. IRS Publication 504 treats a transfer as incident to divorce if it occurs within 1 year after the marriage ends, or if it is made under the divorce instrument and within 6 years. The practical effect is that the spouse who keeps the company also keeps the built-in tax, and pays it whenever the company is eventually sold.
A sale to a third party is different. Long-term gain is generally taxed at 15% or 20% depending on taxable income, with higher rates for certain categories (IRS Topic 409). A 3.8% net investment income tax can also apply above income thresholds of $250,000 for joint filers and $200,000 for single filers (IRS), and whether it reaches a particular owner’s gain turns on how active that owner was. Timing matters as well. IRS Publication 555 lists Texas as a community property state and says a divorce decree ends the marital community, so a closing before the decree and a closing after it can be reported differently. Have the CPA model both.
If the company, rather than the spouse, buys back the departing spouse’s shares, the tax can shift. Treasury Regulation § 1.1041-2 sets default rules that turn on whether the remaining spouse had a primary and unconditional obligation to buy the stock, and it lets spouses state their intended treatment in a written agreement that meets its requirements. This should be drafted with tax advice, not patched in at the end. Interest paid on a buyout note is also generally taxable to the person receiving it, so ask your CPA to separate principal from interest in the model.
Example (hypothetical): Two spouses own an HVAC company in Allen that a valuator puts at $3,000,000, with a tax basis of $200,000, and they plan an equal split, though Texas does not require one. In a buyout at that value, the departing spouse receives $1,500,000 with no gain recognized on the transfer under § 1041. In a sale at the same price, a 10% commission (Robbinex) costs $300,000, leaving a $2,500,000 gain. Federal tax at 20% (IRS Topic 409) takes $500,000, so each spouse nets about $1,100,000 before other fees and taxes. The $400,000 gap is the argument: the owner says the buyout price should reflect costs and tax built into the company, and the departing spouse answers that no sale is planned and those costs may never arrive. How far a Texas judge would credit that argument depends on the evidence, so it is usually more productive to price it in settlement. These figures only illustrate the math and predict nothing.
How a buyout gets funded
The price is half the negotiation. These are the usual sources, often in combination.
- Offset with other community assets. The departing spouse takes more of the home equity, brokerage accounts or retirement funds. Compare assets after tax, because a pre-tax retirement dollar is not worth the same as a dollar in a brokerage account.
- Conventional or SBA financing. The SBA’s 7(a) program has a $5 million maximum and covers complete or partial changes of ownership. Under rules effective October 1, 2026 (SBA Information Notice 5000-880695), lender counsel Starfield & Smith describes owner buyouts as having a 10% equity baseline the lender may reduce or remove, a 1.25:1 debt service coverage requirement, and a requirement that an original owner stay and personally stand behind the loan. Ask the lender early whether it would treat a spouse’s community interest as an owner buyout, because that answer may decide the structure.
- A promissory note to the departing spouse. This is the most flexible source and the most exposed. The decree and note should cover the interest rate, payment schedule, acceleration on default, a pledge of the ownership interest, limits on owner distributions while the note is unpaid, financial reporting, and payoff if the company is sold.
- A look-back clause. If the departing spouse fears a quick resale at a higher price, the agreement can share a portion of any excess if the company sells within a set period. This often closes the gap between two valuations.
For what a valuation itself runs and what drives the fee, see How Much Does a Business Valuation Cost in a Texas Divorce?.
How a sale works inside a divorce
A sale needs more cooperation than a buyout because both spouses have to live with the process for months, often while the case is pending. Put these terms in a signed agreement or an agreed order before a broker is hired:
- Authority. Who runs the company, who deals with the broker, and who signs.
- Price floor. The lowest price either spouse must accept, and what happens to offers below it.
- Proceeds. Where the money sits until the decree, such as an escrow account, and how the tax reserve is calculated before any split.
- Deal risk. How holdbacks, earnouts and later indemnity claims are shared, since those can surface after the divorce is final.
- Owner payments. Whether a noncompete payment, employment contract or transition fee to the operating spouse counts as sale price to share or as pay for future work.
- Fallback. If no letter of intent is signed by a set date, one spouse may buy at the valuator’s figure, or the case proceeds to trial on the buyout question.
Budget for broker commission, commonly around 10% on a range of 5% to 12% or more, with larger deals often on a descending scale (Robbinex), plus legal, accounting and closing costs. Also weigh the costs that do not appear on an invoice: employees and customers tend to hear about a sale, and buyers will ask for the same financial records that are being fought over in discovery.
Who each option fits
A buyout tends to fit when:
- One spouse runs the company and wants to keep it, and the other has no operating role.
- There are enough other assets or borrowing capacity to pay most of the price up front.
- Much of the value would fall away if the owner left, so a third-party sale would be hard to complete.
- The company’s loans, licenses or contracts make a change of ownership difficult.
A sale tends to fit when:
- Neither spouse wants to run the business, or both were ready to exit anyway.
- The company is too large relative to the rest of the estate to offset, and lenders will not fund the difference.
- The spouses are far apart on value, and a real market price would end the dispute.
- Both spouses work in the business and cannot keep working together.
- There is already a credible buyer or a letter of intent.
Example (hypothetical): A solo dental practice in Plano has one dentist-owner, and the other spouse works elsewhere. Much of the value may trace to the dentist’s personal reputation, so the divisible portion could be well below what a practice broker quotes. A buyout using offsetting assets is likely worth modeling first. A sale would make sense mainly if the dentist already intended to retire, and even then the spouses would need to decide how to treat what the buyer pays for the dentist’s transition and noncompete.
When to choose which: a practical sequence
- Confirm character and ownership. Trace formation, capital contributions and any premarital or gift claim, and pull the company documents.
- Get a value you can defend. Decide whether to retain one joint valuator or separate ones, and agree on the valuation date and standard if you can.
- Run the tax model on both paths. Have the CPA show after-tax dollars to each spouse under a buyout and a sale at the same price.
- Test the funding. Get a lender’s preliminary read and list the assets available for offset. If most of the price would sit on an unsecured note, treat that as a warning sign.
- Ask whether a buyer exists. A broker’s informal read on marketability is useful, and it should be handled carefully so it does not alarm staff or customers.
- Take the options to mediation. A mediated settlement agreement that meets the requirements of § 6.602 is binding, so have the funding and tax terms ready before you sit down, not after.
A couple can also combine the two: a buyout now with a look-back clause, or a time-limited sale effort with a buyout fallback. Those hybrids often resolve the fear each spouse has about the other’s numbers.
What to gather before you meet with us
- Several years of business and personal tax returns, financial statements and the general ledger
- Operating agreement, shareholder agreement, buy-sell agreement and any amendments
- Loan documents, personal financial statements given to lenders, and leases
- Any prior valuation, offer, letter of intent or buyer inquiry
- Payroll records and a list of personal expenses run through the company
- Any premarital or marital property agreement
Before you act, read Mistakes Business Owners Make in a Texas Divorce. If the company is one part of a larger estate, High-Net-Worth Divorce in Plano and Collin County covers the wider picture.
Mark L. Scroggins, Managing Partner of Scroggins Law Group, PLLC, is Board Certified in Family Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and has been licensed in Texas since 1993. The firm practices family law only and works with business owners from our Plano office at 5851 Legacy Circle, Suite 600, Plano, TX 75024. To talk through your numbers, call 214-469-3100.
FAQ
Can a Texas judge make me sell my business in a divorce?
Section 7.001 gives the judge broad discretion to make a just and right division. It does not require a sale and does not rule one out. An agreed structure lets you set the terms yourselves rather than leaving them to the court.
Does the spouse being bought out owe tax on the payment?
Generally not on the transfer itself if it qualifies as incident to divorce under 26 U.S.C. § 1041. Interest on a note is a separate question, and a company stock redemption follows its own rules, so confirm your structure with a CPA.
Should the buyout price match what an outside buyer would pay?
Not automatically. A valuator estimates the value of the divisible interest, which may exclude personal goodwill under Nail v. Nail, while a buyer pays for what it expects to receive, including the owner’s transition help. The spouses can also negotiate over built-in tax and sale costs.
What happens if my former spouse stops paying the buyout note?
Your remedies depend on what the decree and note say, which is why acceleration, a pledge of the ownership interest and financial reporting matter. The court can enforce the division and clarify how it is carried out under § 9.006, but it cannot rewrite the substantive deal.
This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.